When 12-year-old Nicole Bradford is left orphaned by her mother's passing, she is placed in the custody of two quarreling former best friends, both of whom are suspected of being her biological father: conservative financial advisor Michael Taylor (Paul Reiser, Mad About You) and liberal artist Joey Harris (Greg Evigan, TekWar.)

Also starring Chad Allen (Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman), football great Dick Butkus and Vonni Ribisi (Saving Private Ryan).

Season Two guest stars include Crystal Bernard, Morgan Fairchild, Davy Jones, Richard Moll, Peter Noone, Emma Samms and baseball great Willie Mays.